↑
logo

GrapheneOS claims Google is now waging war against it, could lock Pixel bootload

Posted by jeena |an hour ago |21 comments

ChrisArchitect an hour ago

noident 41 minutes ago[1 more]

I've been on GrapheneOS for 3 years and I'm never going back to stock android. Once my phone stops being supported I'll switch to whatever hardware runs GrapheneOS. If that can't be done I will buy an iPhone with nothing but Signal and my authenticator app on it and turn on lockdown mode.

I am done dealing with built-in adware draining my battery and carrier bloat.

9cb14c1ec0 an hour ago[2 more]

Android enthusiasts are the buyers keeping Google Pixel alive. I cannot for the life of me understand why Google seems to hate Android enthusiasts.

purpleidea an hour ago[1 more]

Bad news in general if true. The motorola phone prices are insane, so only the Pixels are really a viable option atm.

Make it illegal to lock down hardware like phones and cars.

I like GrapheneOS but the rug pull will eventually happen there too-- they're militantly anti-Copyleft, but using GPLv3+ would prevent many from playing those kinds of lockdown games.

eddythompson80 31 minutes ago

Graphene really confuses me. They are, in terms of the personalities of people involved, eccentric to say the least. I don’t see a problem with that myself as plenty of security and privacy or even OSS are eccentric people. However it does make understanding their communication a bit of an art.

Also I don’t understand some of their technical choices, and due to the aforementioned eccentricity, it’s not productive to have a conversation with them about it.

The technical issues I don’t understand are: they insist their patched sandboxed GSM is superior to a reimplementation like microG, which is fine. But they can also surely consider a sandboxed microG. There is just no world where i see where grabbing a proprietary binary from a corporation and redistributing it with your own modification is ever gonna fly legally for any hw “partner”. There are many non-Google flavores of android that companies have been shipping just fine. Graphenes issues are entirely self imposed that it just borderlines on odd.

Another is their complete dependency on Google devices because of some self imposed requirement. People got reasonably upset when MS said “next windows requires a tpm”. It’s also just really odd.

gunalx an hour ago[2 more]

This is why its important for graphene to exsist on non pixels as well.

Freak_NL an hour ago[1 more]

My partner just upgraded from a Pixel 6 to a Pixel 10a, and because she needed a smartphone for work to (mandatory for auth, but fully paid for by her employer) she got the same Pixel 10a in a different colour.

The difference in just the user experience between her personal GrapheneOS device and the stock Android is huge. GrapheneOS may focus on security and privacy, but out-of-the-box it just offers a much cleaner install.

It sucks that Google is doing this. The past few years there has been a constant trickle of negative articles about Google locking down AOSP and hindering GrapheneOS. If there was some business case there it might make sense, but I get the impression that all GrapheneOS caused was more security for Android, and letting Google sell more Pixels.

The current state of devices which support GrapheneOS is not so nice. The choice is basically between Pixel 10a (around €400) or 10 pro (around €650) — as GrapheneOS cannot support Pixel 11 due to more Google lameness — or this new Motorola Signature 27 (around €1400).

Come on Google. Stop sucking at least on this front OK?

jon128 35 minutes ago

Should be unlawful to sell a device where the device owner can not fully control the bootloader.

A locked bootloader is a form of grand larceny.

vfclists an hour ago[1 more]

No Problemo.

With all the reverse engineering capability offered by AI and the agents it is now a great time to start reverse engineering the shit out of these phones and all these other hardware blobs.

Someone just did it for an Apple trackpad.

https://www.reddit.com/r/emacs/comments/1xydykw/emacs_in_the...

Ungh an hour ago

This is why I use an iPhone. Apple are well-defined assholes. Google on the other hand are unpredictable assholes.